Pop quiz: What’s the scariest of the four elements? Fire might be the obvious choice, but when you really consider the ocean—from its unknowable vastness to its terrifying power and the diversity of creatures who call it home—water is a sneakily strong contender. Perhaps that’s why there’s nothing like a rip-roaring survival yarn from the high seas, a subgenre so popular that a canon has surfaced from the roiling depths. Whether penned by masterful historians and authors or relayed via the firsthand accounts of passengers, crew, and other survivors, these are 12 of the most perilous sea tales ever told.

In the Heart of the Sea
A Night to Remember
Dead Wake
Endurance
The Bering
438 Days
The Perfect Storm
Ghosts of the Tsunami
Into the Raging Sea
Indianapolis
The Wager
The Mysterious Case of Rudolf Diesel