Bony and the Black Virgin

An Inspector Napoleon Bonaparte Mystery

De: Arthur W. Upfield

Narrado por: Peter Hosking

Detective-Inspector Napoleon Bonaparte is called to the drought-stricken outback for this, his latest case. At a desolate sheep station two men have been savagely beaten to death and it's Bony's job to make an arrest. This isn't an easy case, since clues are scarce in this sun-baked, sand-blown country, but Bony's understanding of the bush and the people who live there - both black and white - leads him inexorably to the killer...More mayhem? Listen to another Inspector Napoleon Bonaparte Mystery.©2013 William Upfield. Published in association with ETT Imprint. (P)2010 Bolinda Publishing

Reseñas de la Crítica

"Bony – a unique figure among top-flight detectives." (BBC)

Love the stories, but….

In his later books, Arthur Upfield seem to be using more profanity. That is disappointing.

BonyFan

If you like Inspector Napoleon books you will enjoy reading this book. It is well written and interesting.

bony the best

Would you consider the audio edition of Bony and the Black Virgin to be better than the print version?

yes and no i like the print version of arthur upfied books but the audio is good peter hoskings is a great narrator and i like the way he reads a story

Did the plot keep you on the edge of your seat? How?

it again in the upfield style keeps you thinking the plot out

Which scene was your favorite?

the scene at the end but no spoiler told here

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

no i just enjoyed a well read story as i enjoy this character a his exploits no better bush detective story writer of the era than arthur upfield his knowledge of australia and its bush folk

Any additional comments?

there are a few more books by this author i hope that are read by peter in the future

Don't Start Here

If you are looking to get started on this series, I would suggest looking elsewhere. You can find lists of original publication order online. While the books stand alone, there are some recurring characters and references to past cases that are missed if you jump around. That said, I started with Mr. Jelly's Business, which is representative of the series. Death of a Swagman and An Author Bites the Dust are both pretty good samples as well.

If you have thoroughly enjoyed hearing of Bony's exploits, you will probably have listened to this one without bothering to read reviews. :)

This is one of the later books in the Bony series (I do wish these were ordered as other series are on this site), and it is the worst I've read/heard. The plot is, at the same time, predictable, affectedly convoluted, ill-thought out and peculiar (but somehow not engagingly so). It comes across as almost ideological. The characters are underdeveloped and unsympathetic (mostly). While Bony is always the lead in these stories, the secondary lead is always the setting. Usually, they make a most compelling team. In this book, however, they both seemed flat.

The book has an overall feel of having been a slight experiment, or moment of inspiration, that was rushed in order to get it over with as quickly as possible (i feel the same way abou Agatha Christie's The Big Four). While it is not hugely different in concept from the formula of the other books, the changes seem to be part of the reason it falls short. Don't get me wrong, I like change, but I prefer it to be for the better.

There is also considerably more vitriol in this book. This is only the second book in the series where the publishers warning of racism and sexism seemed apt. (Not that these themes don't show up in the other books; it is a subtle difference that requires more thought than I can voice here.) If you know you will not be able to look past offensive language and actions in the name of accurate depiction, you should probably give the whole series a miss.


As always, Peter Hosking does a fantastic job bringIng to life the people and the setting. There just wasn't much life in the story to begin with.