Broadsides: The Age of Fighting Sail, 1775-1815

De: Nathan Miller

Narrado por: David Rapkin

In the late 18th century, it was widely thought that to be a sailor was little better than to be a slave. "No man will be a sailor," wrote Samuel Johnson, "who has contrivance enough to get himself into jail. A man in jail has more room, better food, and commonly better company."

If that were true, historian Nathan Miller suggests, then the record of sailing in the age of tall ships would likely be distinguished by few heroes and fewer grand narratives. He counters that in the regular navies of England, the fledgling United States, and most other nations, brutal captains and thuggish crewmen were rare, and professionalism was the order of the day. It was their high standard of service that made those naval forces such powerful, even indispensable arms of the land-based military. Miller's great hero throughout this fine history is Horatio Nelson, whose valor was exemplary throughout countless battles around the world. But he writes with equal admiration of lesser-known figures, such as Lambert Wickes, Pierre de Villeneuve, Juan de Cordova, and "Foul Weather Jack" Byron, who served their nations and fellow sailors well, and often heroically.

Download the accompanying reference guide.©2000 Nathan Miller (P)2014 Audible, Inc.

Reseñas de la Crítica

"Pace the pitching black deck with a sleepless Admiral Nelson the night before battle bestows eternal rest and peerless immortality upon him; envision with Mahan the storm-tossed and ever-watchful ships-of-the-line that kept England secure from invasion; wonder in awe at Collingwood's dedication in working himself to death after Trafalgar elevated him to primary responsibility for England's imperial safety in the Mediterranean. All of this and more awaits the reader who will sail through these pages, every one of which is etched with the indelible expertise and boundless enthusiasm of Nathan Miller, master of naval history." (Kenneth J. Hagan, Professor of History and Museum Director Emeritus, U.S. Naval Academy, Professor of Strategy, U.S. Naval War College)

"This is not just inspired naval history--the personal lives of the seafarers themselves, from cabin boy to admiral, are given generous treatment." (The Times (London)

"A wealth of detail...Descriptions of dreadful living conditions aboard cramped wooden vessels give way to bloody decks after close combat....A solid introduction to a turbulent era at sea." (Publishers Weekly)

"[As] a companion to the popular nautical novels of C. S. Forester and Patrick O'Brian--it succeeds brilliantly." (Daily Telegraph [London])

"The descriptions of the great sea commanders and their battles display all the craft of the gifted writer....Read Broadsides for enjoyment as a well-informed, action-packed naval narrative." (The Christ Church Press

Some Big Battles were too short

It is a great book and it does tell the battles from 1775 until 1815, but I felt he could have talked about Trafalgar and The Battle of the Nile in more details. Those were very bill battles and they impacted the Napoleonic Wars Considerably. The lesser known battles in the America's could have been less because in my view they were.
All in all there are very few books like this that you can read that address the peak of the age of the sail. All in all I liked it and would recommend it.

Well written book, not so well read

I found the book to be more than just a rehash of all of the other naval references I have read. It was certainly worth listening to. However, the reader failed to make an appropriate effort with foreign names. Most people have never heard of the Balearic Islands, but the person who would listen to this book almost certainly has, so it's worth checking the pronunciation. He did a creditable job with most names that were obviously French, but I found that his screwing up some critical place names was really annoying. Having said that, it has to be tough on a reader of audiobooks to always know what languages and unique colloquial pronunciations are going to appear. So, four stars for effort.

Full details lacking in other stories

Would you consider the audio edition of Broadsides: The Age of Fighting Sail, 1775-1815 to be better than the print version?

This book puts all the other stories into order and it helps you realize the other naval books of the time have a degree of truth.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Broadsides: The Age of Fighting Sail, 1775-1815?

I enjoyed many, I have read so many books that it all feel into place.

Which scene was your favorite?

Not just one, I have alot of scenes that happened in different parts of history

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Both, I could cry when the foolish govenments would treat the poor sailors very poorly, and be happier when they rewarded those who deserved it.

Any additional comments?

In history this wasnl't really that long, but the changes made to the world are still felt today. Steam ended these mens skilled talents and the world got alittle smaller.

Surprisingly gripping

The battles are vivid, and the politics are interesting. Its worth your time. My only problem is that it seems more narrow in focus then the subtitle would suggest. It is a history of the American and Royal Navy, no more, no less.

Misleading description, solid historical summary

The Audible description focuses on the supposed overturning of the stereotype of brutal treatment of sailors, and I bought it on that basis expecting to get a different perspective. But that is a miniscule part of the book, covered almost just in passing, as the author concentrates on delivering a summary of the history of war at sea in the period encompassing the War of Independence and the Napoleonic wars. Since much of this is ground I'm already familiar with in greater detail than provided here, I was disappointed.

I'll also note I'm constantly surprised at the lack of quality control on these works; this one at least has none of the frequent changes in mixing levels that appear in many others, but the narrator introduces many inappropriately long pauses in the middle of sentences.

That said the book is a solid history, and worth getting on those grounds as long as one isn't expecting something different.

Not an easy task for a historian to dwell...

...on such a narrow subject - with all the details attendant to the task - and not become tedious. Nonetheless, Nathan Miller does a more than commendable job in telling his tale. Crisp writing and compelling narrative, Miller informs and entertains. Almost like a Patriick O’Brian Novel, Miller admirably captures the mystic and reality of the iron men and wooden ships who sailed and fought in a remarkably tumultuous and history changing three decades

well researched...

excellent research, fascinating detailed, and definitive narrative on a age of maritime history. Brings to light what was a formative time period for those island nations dependent upon sea power. JB Hall. USCG, usmma 95

Absolute Best Naval History I Ever Read

This book should be a primer for anyone interested in the age of fighting sail. Well written and well performed.
1. This book explains how ships of the line, in that period functioned.
2. It explained the politics of those men who sailed the ships, in the time that they lived - which is just not done.
3. It is a new approach to world history, seeing things through the naval force rather than land force.

The author gives his interpretation of Napoleon Bonapart's relation with his navy, as opposed to his army, as well as a fledging country - America - trying to defend itself against a naval superpower. The autor is right on on the mark and so wonderfully understandable.

Great book

There are some slight differences with Britain's version of how accounts transpired so if your after how a specific event really happened further research may be required, but its still a great book and well worth the purchase.

a definitive history of sail and combat

this book appears to be extremely well researched and the story writing is first rate. there is a lot of detail in the many descriptions outlined in this very compelling piece of literature. the narration which can ruin a great book or make a bad book come alive is first rate. I put this narrator on the level of Grover Gardner. if 18th & 19thb century sail and sea combat is your jam, you will love this book