The Sultan's Seal

De: Jenny White

Narrado por: Nadia May

The body of a young Englishwoman washes up in Istanbul wearing a pendant inscribed with the seal of the deposed sultan. The death resembles the unsolved murder of another Englishwoman, 10 years before. A magistrate in the new secular courts, Kamil Pasha, sets out to find the killer, but his dispassionate belief in science and modernity is shaken by betrayal and widening danger. In a mystical voice, a young Muslim woman recounts her own relationship with one of the dead women and with the suspected killer. Were these political murders involving the palace or crimes of personal passion?

Rich in sensuous detail, this novel of faith and desire brilliantly captures the political and social upheavals of the waning Ottoman Empire and the contradictory desires of the human soul.

©2006 Jenny White (P)2006 Blackstone Audiobooks

Reseñas de la Crítica

"The writing is lyrical and the characters enchanting." (Publishers Weekly)
"Court life and customs in old Istanbul are thrillingly captured here, with readers easily transported back to those days when mystery and intrigue lurked around every corner." (Booklist)

Interesting setting, but drags a bit

Jenny White clearly knows her setting and uses it to good advantage in this story. But there are too many characters that are not clearly enough drawn to distinguish them from each other, and it makes the intrigues difficult to follow at points. At times the writing drags a bit. It could have been tightened up some with a good edit. And there were a few too many loose ends for my liking. Still all-in-all not a bad read and a reasonable freshman effort. I understand that the next in the series copes with some of these issues (though I haven't read it yet). Those who like the Amelia Peabody series will probably like the Kamil Pasha books.

Nadia May is an excellent narrator for the most part, but her "American" is pretty atrocious: I believe Bernie is from Boston, but she gives him a stereotypical "western" drawl. Still, I'm fond of her as a narrator and recommend her.

The Sultan's Seal

The book is interesting. Unfortunately, the narration left a lot to be desired. The Turkish was mispronounced and the accents sounded more like they were from India rather than Turkey. It would have been better if it had sounded more authentic.

Fascinating novel, flawed reading

I think one might be inclined to discount this book as yet another romantic suspense. Set in the Victorian period, it is a solid novel that presents a fascinating glimpse of Turkey easing itself into the modern era and dealing with issues such as the role of women and the role of religion in government. It has great characters and a well explicated plot that reveals corruption and ruthlessness.

Unfortunately it is not a great listen. The reader, although not as bad as another reviewer says, is hampered by a recording quality that makes her voice sound muffled. The book uses 3 viewpoints, and, at least until a couple of hours into the book, it was hard for me to get a grip on one of them.

If you enjoy historical mysteries that requre a bit of attention, I would recommend ti

Mildly Disappointing.

I listened to "The Abyssinian Proof" first and loved it, and was looking forward to another Kamil Pasha mystery. However, this one is written in third person, present tense, which really doesn't work. Contrary to the other reviews, I found Nadia May's narration to be perfectly adequate. It's the actually narrative POV I had problems with.

Characters' motivations left unresolved

Enjoyed this book because it was set in Istanbul and gave a little glimpse into the late stages Ottoman Empire life. But I found the plot difficult to follow and frankly not terribly believable. Some characters' motivations were left unresolved.