Peter Massa, Partner, Armstrong Teasdale, is interviewed by Habitat Magazine's Bill Morris.

• A legal landmark. The business judgment rule has been around in corporate law for a long time. The theory is that board decisions will not be second-guessed by the courts — provided they’re made in furtherance of the corporation's legitimate interest and in accordance with the recommendation of the corporation’s professionals and the governing documents.
• It’s not failsafe. The caveat here is you generally don't have business judgment rule protection if you're acting in bad faith, outside of the board's authority and against what your governing documents say, or if you’re not following the advice of your professionals.
• Case in point. I represented a condominium that had fireplaces in the apartments. When it was discovered that the chimneys weren't properly lined and fireproofed, engineers told the board it had to get this done because it’s a life-safety issue. The board was facing potential litigation on two fronts — one group didn’t want to spend the money because the fireplaces had never been a problem, and another group threatened to sue if the board did this because it was going to be a big assessment.
• What should the board do. The board should rely on the advice of the engineers. If someone sued, the board’s decision would be upheld because of the business judgment rule. While that case didn't go to litigation, that's how it would be applied. If you can show in court that you were trying to do what was best for the corporation or condominium — even if it was wrong — courts generally will grant you broad leeway.

The business of running a building is demanding work that requires making endless decisions — some that can quickly lead your board into a quagmire of legal difficulties. Legal Talk interviews New York's leading co-op/condo attorneys to find solutions, and get some guidance, on these challenges. For more co-op and condo insights, sign up to receive Habitat's free newsletters or become a Habitat subscriber today!

Leni Morrison Cummins, Partner, Cozen O’Connor, is interviewed by Habitat Magazine's Carol Ott.

It all starts when sponsors decide how they’re going to allocate expenses between the residential and commercial portions of the building. Real Property Law 339M gives sponsors the ability to allocate expenses based on something other than a percentage of common interest. When a sponsor is looking to market their building, they want to keep the allocation of expenses for the commercial units down. So they’ll keep an eye toward minimizing the common expenses.

Expenses go up over the years, but a board doesn’t typically have the authority to change an allocation of expense methodology without commercial unit-owner consent. And if the commercial unit-owner decides it doesn’t want to pay more, fair or not, it can refuse.

Can a true-up fix things? It depends. A true-up is an accounting of the difference between what a board budgets for the year ahead and the actual expenses at the end of that year. The bylaws will determine whether a board can legally true-up. If they say common expenses are allocated and charged based on actual expenses, it can. But if the bylaws simply discuss creating common charges based on a budget, then a true-up isn’t necessary. In practice, though, many condos true-up even if it’s not contained in the bylaws because their accountants direct them to do so.

Just make sure your managing agent understands the prescribed allocation methodology and how it’s applied. If you do see something completely out of whack, approach the commercial unit-owners and see if they will agree to something more reasonable. If not, you’re stuck with what the bylaws say.

The business of running a building is demanding work that requires making endless decisions — some that can quickly lead your board into a quagmire of legal difficulties. Legal Talk interviews New York's leading co-op/condo attorneys to find solutions, and get some guidance, on these challenges. For more co-op and condo insights, sign up to receive Habitat's free newsletters or become a Habitat subscriber today!

Benjamin Flavin, Partner, Braverman Greenspun, is interviewed by Habitat Magazine's Carol Ott.

Lessons for Co-op & Condo Board Directors

• The benefits. HDFC co-ops were created to provide affordable housing for people who may not otherwise be able to enter the New York City real estate market. There are also certain tax benefits that lower the cost of owning an HDFC apartment.
• The regulatory agreement. Most modern HDFCs have a regulatory agreement with New York City that outlines the financial regulations they’re subject to. I think this can be very difficult for boards because sometimes the agreements are not very clear.
• Take flip taxes, for example. These are often determined when the HDFC was created. Many modern HDFCs have a 70/30 flip-tax ratio — 30% of the sale’s profit goes to the HDFC, and 70% goes to the shareholder. But older HDFCs have a 60/40 flip tax, where 40% of the profit goes back to the city, and the shareholder gets 60%. The HDFC is totally left out of the mix.
• Where to locate documents. Many of the documents, like the co-op’s certificate of incorporation, can be obtained from the state. Things like the deed and regulatory agreements are recorded publicly and can be found on ACRIS. And the proprietary lease, bylaws and other such documents can be found in the offering plan in their original form.
• Keep current. One of the most important things for HDFC board members is to understand their co-op’s governing documents. They’ve changed over the years, so if you’ve read something or heard something about HDFCs you should go read your particular documents and find out if whatever you’ve heard applies to your particular co-op.

The business of running a building is demanding work that requires making endless decisions — some that can quickly lead your board into a quagmire of legal difficulties. Legal Talk interviews New York's leading co-op/condo attorneys to find solutions, and get some guidance, on these challenges. For more co-op and condo insights, sign up to receive Habitat's free newsletters or become a Habitat subscriber today!