Send us a text

A nameless girl lay in a Florida forest for decades, filed under Judy Doe and lost to a noisy era of serial predators and thin evidence. Forty years later, genetic genealogy restores her identity—Rebecca Sue Hill, a teenager from Arkansas—and forces us to confront how a single misidentification can bury a case and mute a family’s questions for a generation.

We walk through the case from both ends: an Arkansas disappearance in the early 80s and a body found near Lake Dorr in 1984. The environmental realities—Florida heat, rapid decomposition—shrunk the evidence window, while a misstep in Little Rock prematurely closed Rebecca’s missing status. That mistake separated two investigations that needed each other. Add in a crowded field of suspects and confessors—Christopher Wilder’s east coast rampage, Henry Lee Lucas and Ottis Toole’s performative admissions—and it becomes clearer why the truth stalled. The most compelling person of interest, Michael Roaning, is documented in Lake County the day before the remains were found and later tied to an Arkansas murder. He traded information in other cases yet stayed quiet here, raising the hard question: is silence strategy or distance from the crime?

We also unpack the science that put a name back on the headstone. Investigators leveraged genealogical matches and family mitochondrial lines to verify identity, proving how modern DNA can correct the record even when it can’t deliver a conviction. From there, we examine offender profiles that fit the facts: a traveling, organized killer moving along interstate routes, focused on control over chaos. And we face the collateral damage of the earlier mistake—the Arkansas woman once buried under Rebecca’s name is nameless again and needs exhumation and testing to get her identity back.

If you care about true crime that values accuracy over easy answers, this story matters. Come for the forensic insights and case mapping; stay for the hard truths about how systems fail, and how science, persistence, and community can still make things right. Subscribe, share this episode with a friend who loves investigative storytelling, and leave a review to help others find the show. Your feedback and tips can move cases like this forward.

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!

Send us a text

The story starts on a quiet May evening in 1991 and never really stops echoing. A nine-year-old sets out to sell costume jewelry in a tiny Arkansas town where people wave from porches and the fields hold the day’s last light. By week’s end, she’s found in a ditch four miles away, and everything residents believe about safety, trust, and “being home before dark” begins to crack.

We walk you through what happened and what didn’t: kids who saw a light-blue car and a man with long hair; a grocery stop that raised more questions than it answered; and a case that leaned on one hair in a suspect’s car—then fell apart when the wrong hairs were sent to the FBI. The ex-wife who first pointed to him never made it to the stand, and without cross-examination, her statement vanished. With no solid DNA and water erasing traces, the courtroom math never added up. Along the way, we unpack how small agencies in 1991 worked without homicide units, how early DNA limits changed everything, and why eyewitness memory—especially from children—can both illuminate and mislead.

This isn’t a tidy true-crime tale. It’s a study in the limits of process, the cost of a single forensic error, and the burden families carry when “closure” is an empty word. We talk candidly about motive theories—from robbery gone cruel to a witness silenced—and why each sits on uncertain ground. We also explore how modern tools, offender registries, and renewed records searches might open doors that stayed shut for decades. If you lived in or around Hickory Ridge back then, your detail—an unfamiliar car, a sudden move, a changed routine—could matter more than you think.

If this episode moves you, share it with someone who grew up in the Delta, hit follow so you don’t miss future deep dives, and leave a review to help others find the show. And if you know something—anything—about that night, call the Arkansas State Police. Let’s try again to turn an open question into an answer.

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!

Send us a text

A simple errand, a stamped receipt at 3:17 p.m., and a car left on US 71 with the keys still in the ignition. We walk through the last verified hours of 18-year-old Dana Stidham and sort what’s true from what’s been repeated for decades. No theatrics—just timestamps, locations, and choices that still demand answers: the unfixed flat, the Omni facing the wrong way, and a seven-week silence broken by a hunter who waited before calling his discovery in.

We unpack why those details matter in a rural 1989 Bella Vista—before cell phones, before robust DNA workflows, and before trails cut through deep Ozark terrain. We look at early suspects and fragile alibis, including a boyfriend whose grief blurred lines but not evidence, and we press on the questions that keep resurfacing: Was the tire sabotaged? Did someone move the Omni to misdirect the search? What did investigators document about the tire, trunk, and missing items that could signal a souvenir? Along the way, we separate rumor from record on “serial killer” talk in the Ozarks and focus on what the case can actually sustain.

We also examine behavior that sets off alarms—the delayed call from the man who found remains—and consider what modern profiling says about witness conduct versus narrative control, without leaping past the facts. Then we outline our next steps: FOIA requests for the officer sighting, tire photos, and evidence inventories; outreach to Benton County; and an open invitation for locals who remember that stretch of US 71 to come forward with specifics. If you drove those roads, worked those shifts, or owned a similar pickup, your memory might tighten the timeline.

If this case gripped you, share the episode with someone who knows northwest Arkansas, subscribe for updates as records come in, and leave a review with the one question you want answered most. Your perspective could nudge a detail out of the past and into the file that finally moves.

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!

Send us a text

Ever wondered what dark secrets lurk beneath the surface of America's quiet small towns? In this episode, Paul and Andrea pull back the curtain on two shocking criminal cases from Northwest Arkansas that time has nearly forgotten.

The conversation begins with a puzzling 1972 case where Lieutenant Carl Martins, a young Springdale police officer, survived when a bomb detonated under his car right at the police station. Despite involvement from the FBI, ATF, and even a grand jury investigation, the case went cold with surprising speed. Why would someone attempt a mob-style hit in a town of barely 30,000 people? And why did the story fade from newspapers after just six mentions? The hosts theorize about possible motives while planning to file Freedom of Information Act requests to uncover the truth behind this mysterious attempted murder.

Even more disturbing is the 1974 murder spree of Shirley Marie Curry, a mother who, enraged over losing custody of her children, embarked on a killing rampage across multiple towns. In a single evening, she murdered her two sons, her ex-husband, her daughter, and her ex-husband's half-sister before attempting to kill a sixth victim. When captured, her chilling question to officers—"I missed the sixth one, didn't I?"—revealed her calculated bloodlust. Despite the severity of her crimes, she was initially declared mentally ill and legally irresponsible before eventually spending the remainder of her life in prison.

These forgotten cases reveal how even seemingly quiet communities harbor dark histories that rival more notorious crime capitals. Join Paul and Andrea as they resurrect these cold cases and discuss what they tell us about America's hidden criminal past. Have stories like these been buried in your hometown too? Visit paulgnewton.com for more content as they continue their investigation into these Arkansas mysteries.

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!

Send us a text

Buried in declassified government archives lies a chilling reminder of how fragile democracy can be from within. Operation Northwoods represents one of the most disturbing chapters in American military planning – a moment when the nation's top generals unanimously approved a scheme to attack their own citizens as a pretext for war.

The story begins in 1962, with the United States still reeling from the Bay of Pigs disaster. As Castro consolidated power just 90 miles from Florida, Pentagon leaders grew desperate for justification to launch a full-scale invasion. Their solution? A series of false flag operations targeting Americans themselves. The document, signed by every member of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, methodically outlined proposals including blowing up US ships, staging terrorist attacks in Miami, orchestrating aircraft hijackings, and even potentially sacrificing Cuban refugees – all to be blamed on Castro's Cuba. The clinical language belies the human cost: sailors unwittingly serving as bait, pilots unaware they'd been penciled into death scripts, and Miami families reduced to chess pieces in a geopolitical game.

What saved countless American lives was President Kennedy's firm rejection. When presented with these proposals in March 1962, he drew a moral line that his generals had been willing to cross. The document remained classified for decades until its 1997 release stunned the nation. For veterans who had saluted these same commanders, the betrayal cut especially deep. Operation Northwoods serves as a stark reminder that democracy's greatest threats sometimes wear familiar uniforms, and that vigilance against such internal corruption remains our only safeguard. The plan lies entombed in archives, whispering how close America came to consuming itself – and how one president's moral clarity prevented catastrophe.

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!

Send us a text

Nuclear weapons vanish without a trace. Soviet submarines prepare to launch. False alarms flash across screens in Moscow bunkers. The Cold War was more dangerous than most of us ever realized.

We reveal the shocking truth that at least six American nuclear weapons have been lost since the 1950s and never recovered. These aren't training devices or empty shells—they are fully operational thermonuclear bombs, some capable of yields hundreds of times more powerful than Hiroshima, scattered across oceans and buried in remote locations. The military's clinical term—"broken arrow"—masks the terrifying reality of what these missing weapons represent.

Our survival through the nuclear age wasn't guaranteed by presidential speeches or diplomatic maneuvering. Twice, we came to the brink of nuclear war, and twice, we were saved not by world leaders but by mid-level Soviet officers who refused to follow protocol. Vasili Arkhipov prevented nuclear torpedo launches during the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962. Stanislav Petrov declared a computer warning of American missiles a false alarm in 1983 rather than initiating Soviet retaliation. These men risked everything—careers, freedom, even their lives—to prevent nuclear catastrophe.

The stories are hauntingly specific: A B-47 bomber colliding with a fighter jet over Georgia in 1958, dropping a hydrogen bomb near Tybee Island that remains lost to this day. A B-52 breaking apart over North Carolina in 1961, with investigators later revealing that only a single low-voltage switch prevented detonation of a weapon that could have wiped out much of the eastern seaboard. Four hydrogen bombs scattered across Spain in 1966, two rupturing and spreading plutonium across the countryside.

As nuclear tensions rise again across the globe, these forgotten incidents remind us of an uncomfortable truth: the world's most destructive weapons aren't always under the perfect control we imagine. Our nuclear history isn't about stability—it's about survival by chance.

Listen now and share your thoughts on this eye-opening episode. Email your feedback to paulg@paulgnewton.com and let me know what other hidden historical revelations you'd like explored in future episodes.

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!

Send us a text

In 1927, a “modern cure” for ringworm left a boy’s skull collapsed. He wore a hat for 80 years to hide the truth.

In a rural Black farming town in Indiana, 1927, a group of schoolchildren were told they’d receive a modern medical treatment for ringworm. It was free, it was fast, and it was promised safe. What followed was one of the most chilling medical betrayals of the 20th century.

This is the true story of Vertus Wellborn Hardiman — a five-year-old boy whose skull was irreparably damaged by radiation and who wore a hat for the next eighty years to hide the evidence.

What looks like progress can sometimes be poison.

This isn’t folklore. It’s a hospital record. Read the full story and hear the episode now.

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!

Send us a text

Karen Silkwood's final drive down Highway 74 on November 13, 1974, ended in a crash that silenced a whistleblower and disappeared a folder of evidence that could have shaken America's nuclear industry to its core. This haunting story begins with an ordinary woman who took a job at Kerr-McGee's Cimarron nuclear fuel plant in Oklahoma, hoping for a fresh start after her marriage dissolved. Instead, she discovered a nightmare of negligence that put workers and potentially the public at grave risk.

What Karen found inside those fluorescent-lit halls was chilling: falsified safety records, cracked containment chambers, and most alarmingly, missing quantities of plutonium—enough to construct a dirty bomb. As she began documenting these violations, strange things happened. Radiation appeared in her apartment, contaminating everything from her food to her bathroom fixtures. Doors were found ajar, papers shifted positions, and cars followed her through the Oklahoma darkness. The evidence she gathered became both her shield and her target.

The aftermath of her death triggered investigations by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and congressional hearings that confirmed her allegations. The plant eventually closed, yet justice remained elusive—her family's legal victory was drastically reduced on appeal, and no executives faced criminal charges. Karen Silkwood wasn't perfect; she was stubborn, flawed, and unrelenting. But her courage to speak truth to power, to protect her coworkers and community from invisible danger, transformed her into an enduring symbol of whistleblower courage. Her story raises questions that still burn today: What price do we pay for energy? Who protects workers from powerful interests? And what really happened on that lonely stretch of Highway 74 when a woman carrying secrets collided with silence?

Support the show

Want to host a Podcast? Buzzsprout can help! Use this link to Find out More.

Check out Paul's Website

Want sound like Paul G's for your podcast? Get the plug-ins you need here!