The Whisperers

Private Life in Stalin's Russia

De: Orlando Figes

Narrado por: John Telfer

Drawing on a huge range of sources - letters, memoirs, conversations - Orlando Figes tells the story of how Russians tried to endure life under Stalin. Those who shaped the political system became, very frequently, its victims. Those who were its victims were frequently quite blameless.

The Whisperers re-creates the sort of maze in which Russians found themselves, where an unwitting wrong turn could either destroy a family or, perversely, later save it: a society in which everyone spoke in whispers - whether to protect themselves, their families, neighbours or friends - or to inform on them.

©2018 Orlando Figes (P)2018 Audible, Ltd

Mostly excellent pronunciation of Russian names and phrases

A little repetitive at times, but the author follows characters through the historical process, showing how things turned out in the end.
I understand that the Soviets - both individuals and state - would not comment on their cruel treatment of German women at the war’s end, but some sort of authorial reference might have helped put the “official” story in context.

A moving look at a terrible crime against humanity

I'd recommend it! Gets a little bogged down at points but the fact that the author is speaking for people long since murdered and forgotten by the system that they lived under is important.

Well worth the time invested

It’s not an easy topic and not always easy to follow the story. At the beginning it feels disjointed and lacking in purpose but very quickly Figes paints small brush strokes into a beautiful evolving artwork. Individual stories become a history lesson and pull together to form a plot. This is a masterful telling of Stalinist Russia and the years after.

Man’s Inhumanity to Man

If this book were required reading in the ideologically compromised schools of the western world, the luxury dalliance with Marx would vanish in a generation. Figes takes you by the hand and leads you through a relentless, deeply depressing, and challenging stream of human tragedy caused by Soviet Utopianism. But he does so personally by person, which makes it all the more tragic. The book itself is a challenge to one’s endurance. The horrors spill forth with a relentless, implacable steadiness. Each story represents thousands of others just like it yet unique. Hell on earth, revealed through actual letters, remembrances, and deep archival research. As it turns out, attempting to transform mankind, with all its natural faults, into more perfect beings requires infinite levels of coercion, brutality, and oppression. Millions of broken eggs, to borrow from Stalin; but no omelettes. Not one. Just millions of anguished and long strangled cries, which Figes gives voice to in these very difficult pages. Read it if you want to develop infinite gratitude for real freedom and humanity, but sadly most can’t handle the truth. Not for the faint of heart or the snowflake; but required for those who value human dignity and understand what it takes to oppose those who would crush it.

Required Reading

I have listened to SO many books on the broad topic of Soviet Russia. Despite this, this is the first type of book I have listened to of its kind. the only other book series thus far that is somewhat similar is the Gulag Archipelago series. However, the difference primarily lies in that it follows a limited number of families and what happened to the individual members of those families as a result of living under one of the most readily identifiable totalitarian systems in the past 100 years. It does an outstanding job of bridging the gap between macro third person and micro third person. This book would be enjoyed by anyone interested in the result of philosophy, propaganda, historic examples of the danger of religious faith/scientific faith in human logic, the danger of group think, lovers of Russian history, people of religious faith desiring examples of the consequences of faith in everything but a supernatural, and those fascinated by communism from a position of hate yet high intrigue.