The Amish Temptress #2: Jeb's First Time

By: Anna Josen

Narrated by: Virtual Voice

My name is Ellie, but in my Amish community a lot of grown men call me Madame Eleanor or The Amish Temptress. In private, of course. You see, I was nineteen when I first snuck out to meet a guy, and realized how much fun it is to fulfill a repressed man’s desires. Ever since then, I've been taking care of the men's needs in my community. Giving them the space to satisfy their unmentionable cravings is what I enjoy doing most. It certainly makes my life more interesting around here.

When Jeb approaches me during the Sunday picnic, I fear he’s going to ask for my hand in marriage. Instead, I’m pleasantly surprised when he tells me he’s heard of my reputation as Madame Eleanor, and asks if I would be willing to act out one of his fantasies with him. I’m more than happy to oblige, especially since I have the perfect toy for what he craves.

Jeb’s First Time is a steamy Amish MF short story.

Amish Secrecy (2)

Short, and sweet. Could it be true, maybe? I wish there were a little bit more darker.