My First Mistake

By: Sadie Kincaid

Narrated by: Mollie Stark, Joe Arden

What do you do when your boyfriend cheats on you six days before your brother’s wedding? The same wedding where you’re the maid of honor and the man who obliterated your heart eight years ago is the best man?

I can tell you what you should not do. You should absolutely not have an emotional meltdown and let your soon to be sister-in-law find you crying into a glass of pink wine. Because then she will tell your overprotective big brother that you’re heartbroken (even if you’re not), and he will take it upon himself to ask the one man he trusts above all others to look out for you. Yes, same best man.

And that’s why I arrive at my beautiful secluded cabin in the woods to find Chase Hunter has already made himself at home. Despite how much I’m supposed to hate him, there are certain parts of my anatomy that don’t quite get the memo.

But I will resist at all costs. I’m not the naïve nineteen year old who thought the sun shone out of his … well, you get the picture.

No matter how charming he is, how he still takes care of me in the smallest and sweetest of ways, or how I feel even the slightest brush of his skin more deeply than I’ve felt anything else in years, I will not look into those striking blue eyes and let him fool me again.

He was my first mistake, and one I don’t plan on making again. Except … well, Chase has other ideas. He was my first everything, and he’s determined to be my last.

My First Mistake is a standalone contemporary romance from bestselling author, Sadie Kincaid. It includes:

• Brother's best friend
• Forced Proximity
• Enemies to Lovers
• Groveling
• Best man vs bridesmaid
• Plenty of tension
• Lots of Christmas spice

©2025 Red House Press Ltd. (P)2025 Blue Nose Publishing, Red House Press Ltd.

Amazing!

Sadie never disappoints.. her stories are top tier and Chase & Addie might be my new favorite couple♥️ great voice actors too!

So cute!!

Omg. This was stuck a cute book. I listened to the bonus epilogue on BNA and it got me from page 1! Chase is the ultimate book boyfriend!
After being cheated on by her boyfriend, Jacks baby sister is left to attend his wedding alone. And due to the recent breakup, Jack asks his best friend to keep an eye on her during all the festivities, and he’s more than happy to do so. Chase has been in love with this girl for 8 years. Problem is she hates him since she overheard something he said and it broke her heart.
But knowing how they feel about each other chase isn’t ready to give up on her yet. Can she continue hating him?

This story is spicy, sweet and has the cutest HEA ever!

I’ll take a chase hunter under my Christmas tree

This story was even better in audio! Joe Arden was the perfect narrator for Chase Hunter. The way joe was able to really get into the role of Chase was perfection. He poured so much emotions into this story it was perfec! Mollie! Wow. There has been a few stories I’ve heard with mollie narrating the FMC but this one was her best. The way she brought Addie to life was absolute perfection. She was able to show all the raw emotions of Addie throughout every chapter perfectly. This audio books elevated the story to a different level it was amazing

Sweet little love story!

This was such a cute little story of second chance romance! Joe and Molly were perfection together!

Banter, spice and everything nice

I loved listening to this story! I don’t think I’ve read or listened to a rom com Sadie Kincaid story and I am absolutely here for it!
This was a feel good holiday novella that had laughs and that super spice that Mrs. Kincaid knows how to write oh so well. And let’s not forget the performers who equally bring Sadie’s words to life! Joe Arden and Mollie Stark heat things up in this story! Where ginger will never be looked at the same ever again and a few new vocabulary words to add to my arsenal, this story is definitely-shout it out from the highest snow capped mountain tops- a fun and heartwarming holiday story that will surely keep you warm for this winter season.