His First Girlfriend

By: Nora Valters

Narrated by: Lucy Paterson

A totally binge-worthy psychological thriller with a heart-stopping twist

Your son’s new girlfriend.

Your new worst enemy…?

My heart thuds as the front door swings open, and my precious son Seth walks in with his new girlfriend Lily on his arm. I’m so nervous. But she’s everything I hoped she’d be. Before long, she’s part of the family and staying every evening. We relax together and have long conversations. It’s a dream–Lily is like the daughter I never had.

But as our family dynamic shifts, the precious bond with my husband and son begins to change. I’m convinced they’re avoiding me and talking to me differently… Am I being paranoid, or is Lily turning my loved ones against me?

Then I receive a warning. It hints at a past I’ve tried so hard to erase. My carefully controlled world starts to unravel.

Is the secret I’ve tried so hard to bury about to destroy perfect family?

And can I trust Lily? Or is my life and my son’s life in danger?

An utterly addictive psychological thriller that will have you gasping out loud. If you love None Of This Is True, John Marrs, T.M Logan and Freida McFadden you’ll be gripped by His First Girlfriend.

©2025 Nora Valters (P)2026 Bookouture, an imprint of Storyfire Ltd.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

At one point, I even felt like I was getting gaslight in this story lol. There has to be a special name for this level of grudge holding. Jen was excited when Seth brought Lily home. She was worried about him going off to college and finding his way so she is simply thrilled that he has found his first girlfriend! But when sinister things start to occur, Jen slowly realizes that someone is gaslighting her & there’s only 1 new addition to their circle. This story kept me at the edge of my seat, as Nora Valters absolutely threw in a few twists to make you doubt what you’re thinking & the narrator did an amazing job magnifying every tense filled moment! I was fully invested in the outcome of this domestic thriller and I will definitely be reading more from this author!