His Bloody Project

Documents Relating to the Case of Roderick Macrae

De: Graeme Macrae Burnet

Narrado por: Antony Ferguson

Duración: 10 h y 22 m

Resumen del Editor

The year is 1869. A brutal triple murder in a remote community in the Scottish highlands leads to the arrest of a young man by the name of Roderick Macrae. A memoir written by the accused makes it clear that he is guilty, but it falls to the country's finest legal and psychiatric minds to uncover what drove him to commit such merciless acts of violence. Was he mad? Only the persuasive powers of his advocate stand between Macrae and the gallows.

Graeme Macrae Burnet tells an irresistible and original story about the provisional nature of truth, even when the facts seem clear. His Bloody Project is a mesmerizing literary thriller set in an unforgiving landscape where the exercise of power is arbitrary.

©2016 Graeme MaCrae Burnet (P)2016 Blackstone Audio, Inc.

Slow at first, but ultimately engrossing

It took me a couple of tries to get into this book, which I suspect is a different experience to read than hear due to the footnotes & period language. But once I got about an hour into the story & found my footing with the characters and plot -- I found it engrossing, really interesting in its historical detail, and very thought-provoking. I still don't know quite how I feel about the main character & his actions -- and I was pretty sure I did half way through the tale, so the perspective change in the final half of the book was unexpected and welcome.

I enjoyed the reader a lot and thought he helped ease some of the language barrier.

I don't think this is a book for everyone. But for fans of historical mysteries & psychological mysteries, I'd absolutely recommend.

Interesting

Excellent performance rendering many voices and accents redering characters. If you read this as an intellectual costruct which reveals the author's extensive research, you won't be disappointed.
Tiny quibble with the glossary definition of stirk, but perhaps a part of Scotland where bovine sex denomination is reversed.

A tragedy

From the start, it is predetermined that this will be a tragic story. Although the narration is fine, the format of the book is better read than listened to.

Excellent Everything!

Would you listen to His Bloody Project again? Why?

Yes - it was fascinating in terms of history and the legal aspects. The "footnotes" were wonderfully well done. Thanks for including them!

What did you like best about this story?

How it all worked together - the history, the style, the plot, the characters, the structure, etc.

Have you listened to any of Antony Ferguson’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

I don't think so but I might look for them now though.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

I chuckled a time or two - mostly it made me think and wonder.

Any additional comments?

I loved the footnotes included - thank you.

if you enjoy pointless, depressing stories, read!

great narrator! wish he hadn't been, I wouldn't have wasted so much time. definitely regret.

Gale-force Gothic Tale, 1869 Scottish Highlands

This novel brilliantly seats the reader as detective (or perhaps juror) on the savage, gruesome gouging and murders of the town bully and two of his children in a small farm community on the high coast of Scotland. It's a blend of narrative from the killer and statements to the constable, medical reports and trial transcript, portrayed as a recently discovered manuscript. The issue is not whether he committed the crime but his mental capacity at the time of the murders.

The narrative evokes dark clouds covering a grim community full of poverty, in the laird, the weather, the church, the small crofts, tattered clothes, and a rampaging bully set to suit himself in the way of a teenage lady. It blusters with black humor and just when you think you have it figured out it cold-cocks you with a crucial clue.

His Bloody Project is a gripping psychological thriller that--I like how The Guardian reviewer described it--"play[s] lovingly with the traditions of Scottish literature; an artful portrait of a remote crofting community in the 19th century that showcases theories about class and criminology," says The Guardian.

Most highly recommended.

Very interesting and enjoyable book

I enjoyed this book a lot. The plot was well developed and the characters were reasonably well drawn, given (as it seems to me) the main point of the book was to explore a theme: specifically, the emerging Victorian science of criminal anthropology - trying to codify the influence of genetics on the criminal; and more broadly, how depression and other forms of mental illness may lead to criminal behavior, and to what extent this is a mitigating circumstance. I liked the way the author didn't land heavily on an answer but left many ideas hanging in the air for the listener to explore. He let you see that this was a new concept for the times, but there were a lot of things the Victorians didn't yet understand that we now know, thus introducing some irony in the fate of the character. It was a good story as well!

My main beef was with the choice of narrator. This was a book set in the north of Scotland, where all the characters were Scottish. So why on earth did Audible get an English actor to perform it?? His accent was 90% there but the 10% that wasn't really irritated me. The pace was off because he was trying too hard to get the accent down. He read it in a sing-song intonation which I guess could have been a Highland lilt but I'd have liked a more dour reading, personally. The author wasn't served by the narrator's unfamiliarity with some esoteric words like "demur", which he pronounced as "demure"; "midfrift" for midriff (maybe that's a Scots variant??), especially given this won the Man Booker Prize. I would definitely listen to other books narrated by Antony Ferguson; I just didn't think he was right for this one.

A haunting tale of 19th-century justice in Scotland

This was one of the more compelling reads/listens I have encountered in a while. In the end I still have questions, which in no way diminishes the power of the pros and the depiction of the social order in rural Scotland in the 19th century. I have my own ideas about what really happened, but I’ll leave it to you to find yours.

Outstanding

If you like crime stories that take you back to other times and cultures this is one of the best. After a slow start the story is captivating. Be prepared for a very sad and tragic tale about hard working underappreciated people. The Murderers motives are intriguing and complicated.

Thats it?

The story was riveting, but the ending was a disappointing, especially for a work of nonfiction. The narration was excellent.