The Comanche Empire

De: Pekka Hamalainen

Narrado por: Carla Mercer-Meyer

Duración: 19 h y 51 m

Resumen del Editor

In the 18th and early 19th centuries, a Native American empire rose to dominate the fiercely contested lands of the American Southwest, the southern Great Plains, and northern Mexico. This powerful empire, built by the Comanche Indians, eclipsed its various European rivals in military prowess, political prestige, economic power, commercial reach, and cultural influence. Yet, until now, the Comanche empire has gone unrecognized in American history.

This compelling and original book uncovers the lost story of the Comanches. It is a story that challenges the idea of indigenous peoples as victims of European expansion and offers a new model for the history of colonial expansion, colonial frontiers, and Native-European relations in North America and elsewhere. Pekka Hämäläinen shows in vivid detail how the Comanches built their unique empire and resisted European colonization, and why they fell to defeat in 1875. With extensive knowledge and deep insight, the author brings into clear relief the Comanches' remarkable impact on the trajectory of history.

©2008 Yale University (P)2016 Tantor

Reseñas de la Crítica

"A fascinatingly informative volume." ( Booklist)

outstanding

simply brilliant. This will change your perspective on many subjects. it is well worth the read

wonderful

loved it,astonished by the information given. speaker sounded so elegant. I loved it will hope to pass to others.

Brilliant Scholarly Treatment…

Of Comancheria. The same level of information probably could have been done in less time. But I loved it anyway. The performance by Ms Mercer-Meyer was an A+

More nuanced than traditional portrayals

This book was clearly a monumental undertaking that required a LOT of research that the author synthesizes and sets into chronological order for this book. It's clear the author was attempting to avoid and subvert the depictions of indigenous people that sort them into perfect victim/brave warrior archetypes that always emphasize a lack of organization and mythologize the importance of settling into an agricultural lifestyle in order to be considered a worthwhile culture.
I do think the author improves greatly on previous writings about the Comanche Empire. However, much of the point of view of the story still feels rooted in settler narratives. It's disappointing because you can feel the author trying to resist, but much is done in this book that sanitizes and justified the violent expansion of European settlers into Comanche territory.

I'm confused by some reviews praising the reader's pronunciations of French/Spanish words. Although I think the reader does a remarkable job of trying to lend life to long sections of the book that are essentially dry recitations of dates and events, the Spanish language pronunciation in particular caused me to cringe with each word. Particularly the prominent pronunciation of the "H" in "hacienda," a word that appears not infrequently. I would think it would be possible to find someone who has at least a basic understanding of Spanish pronunciation to read a book that requires the reader to say a lot of Spanish words, but it seems not.
I only have minimal understanding of French and I'm willing to believe that language fares better in this reading, although it didn't hit my ear that way. It's possible I had already become biased by the first pronunciation of "hacienda" at that point.

Overall, if you're interested in learning more about the Comanche Empire this is probably worth a read. I found it to be very imperfect, but I also think I learned a lot. I would certainly not recommend it for anyone who doesn't enjoy academic texts though as this work is very academic and does not read like a pop history book.

An unknown Empire

The author does a great job at not only recounting the history of the Commanche Empire but what motivated its leaders, people, expansion and war. You will never look at a grass prairie again without envisioning how it looked to the Commanche.

Mispronunciations & Fractured Sentences

Well worth reading. Wonderfully informative! It is a shame that it is hobbled by a reading performance that is only a little better than a robotic GPS voice.

Atrocious pronunciation

Audiobook: Unpleasantly cowlike delivery of an important book. Carla Mercer-Meyer's narration is just unlistenably dense with embarrassments — she has jarringly uneven diction and repeatedly jabbed into my ears with misreadings and mispronounciations. I more than once had to rewind while flipping to the printed text because I could hardly believe what I was hearing. In the space of a single page not far into the introduction, she said "empirical" instead of "imperial" and garbled "erratic" into "erotic" — that was it for me. This narrator simply lacks basic qualifications for reading aloud.

The work itself is an exciting scholarly contribution and valuable for anyone interested in Comanche history, colonial North America, imperiogenesis, and rapid cultural reinvention, so I am rather sorry for Pekka Hämäläinen.

A comprehensive evaluation

I have to chuckle at the review of this book that read “The most boring book ever.” I am certain that for many this would be true. However I thoroughly enjoyed it. For sure it is a comprehensive study and evaluation of the Comanche nation dealing with the forces of nature, society and economy that drove the development, existence and failure of Comanche life. I learned so much more about Native American culture that other wonderful books don’t have time to delve into. I cannot give it five stars overall as it was difficult to hang with and needed to take it in stages. I have to wonder if it has been used as a textbook.

marvelous history

Great history that avoids political correctness. Reader is great with tough Native American and Spanish names

Very Finnish approach: detailed, nuanced, without traditional stereotypes but with own culture impacts

It is very well done academic work, you can trust all the facts and details in this book.
The outcomes are interesting and broadening your views on the society and indigenous people and of course the American history and sociocultural issues.
The language and the style are overwhelming and boring for non-academic readers, might be because the native Finnish speakers have the very difficult own language and feel English as very simple even when they speak academically.

As to the narrator it seems to me excellent but I don’t have a lot of experience in this field. It’s just my honest opinion.

I think that it is worth to read and to listen this book, the pluses are weighing much more than minuses. At least I did it twice and I don’t think that I waisted my time for nothing, it was really good for me.
Thank you.