The Most Reluctant Convert

C. S. Lewis's Journey to Faith

By: David C. Downing

Narrated by: Patrick Cullen

His books have sold millions and include classics like Mere Christianity, The Screwtape Letters, and The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Yet C. S. Lewis was not always a literary giant of Christian faith. How did he evolve from staunch atheism to become one of the most beloved and renowned Christian authors of our time?

For C. S. Lewis enthusiasts and students alike, this book offers a unique look at Lewis's personal journey to faith and the profound influence it had on his life as a writer. Written by Professor David C. Downing, author of the critically acclaimed For C. S. Lewis enthusiasts and students alike, this book offers a unique look at Lewis's personal journey to faith and the profound influence it had on his life as a writer. Written by Professor David C. Downing, author of the critically acclaimed Planets in Peril, this thoughtful book is a delight.

©2002 David C. Downing (P)2003 Blackstone Audio, Inc.

Critic reviews

"[A]n intellectual biography that seizes and sustains interest as though it were a spellbinding suspense thriller." ( Booklist)
"Downing focuses on the interior developments in Lewis's thought rather than retelling his conversion story....The narrative's firm foundation in Lewis's thoughts makes it a plausible and joyful creative journey." ( Publishers Weekly)
"Filled with interesting detail about the intellectual and spiritual communities that surrounded Lewis, the analysis is impressive without sounding academic or intellectual." ( AudioFile)

A Myth Come True

Reluctant Convert was a short read, only about 5 hours long, retelling of Lewis' life and an excellent evaluation of the progress he made from childhood imagination through boyhood atheism, materialism, dualism, occultism, pantheism, idealism and finally to adult faith in God and later in Christ as his revelation. What an amazing journey! It was well told and read. Those "-isms" were clearly explained with tons of illustrative material. By the way Downing interprets the Mrs. Moore episode in an honest but sensitive manner. My headline is a Lewis quote that suggests that the revelation of God in Christ captures the essence of the dying rising gods but is profoundly historical in nature. I was thinking that Donald Downing has done us a favour by correcting many of the myths and misreadings of Lewis by giving us the straight goods about Lewis capturing his essential legacy.

A great book on one of my favorite authors

Usually, if I can read the primary sources, I do. My graduate work showed me the downside of critics and those who want to discount or as Lewis states interprets his motive and mindset on his far ranging writings. This author echoed and depended my appreciation and respect for Lewis the man. I learned much from Downing and thank him for writing such a book. I am a better man for it. It is a great read. I even bought the hard copy to stay in my library. It is worth your time and money to read. Respectfully Bill Steinwedell. May 2022 be a break through year for all who read this review.

Excellent story of God winning the rebellion

Fascinating to read of CS's gradual thinking and understanding of the world and God's role in it.

Insightful look into the conversion of CS Lewis

Well researched, well written, well read look into the conversion of a most insightful man.

Scholarly discussion but needs a new reader

This discussion of the background and subsequent conversion to Christianity of C.S.Lewis is well written, interesting and thorough. The reader is adequate, but his decision to affect a British accent when quoting Lewis is jarring. I understand the reader’s desire to let Lewis’s own words stand out, but the accent is inconsistent, inauthentic and just weird…

Officially a favorite. And I'm picky.

CS Lewis is currently one of my top 5 favorite authors of all time and has always been in my top 20. The more I Read of his books the more I like him.
I could never have written something so enlightened, engaging, and informed.
This book is insightful in ways that even a huge CA Lewis fan hadn't seen and is, in my opinion, one of the more valuable book of the past 200 years.
Thank you for this book Mr. Downing and fantastic read, Mr. Cullen.

Excellent insights into Lewis' spiritual journey

Well worth the listen for any Lewis fan or anyone wishing to understand the workings of a first date mind coupled to an insightful intuition and uniquely Irish spirituality.
I had expected to hear the stage play but got something very different, and in many ways, deeper and better.

What a Journey

One of the most significant events of the 20th century was the conversion of one of the English speaking world’s most influential atheists into its most eloquent Christian apologist. When historians consider the most prominent leaders that brought Britain through World War II, C. S. Lewis and Churchill are at the top of the list with Churchill handling the military and political side and C. S. Lewis handling the spiritual side. And, Lewis had not just been a casual atheist. At 17 he wrote to a friend, "I believe in no religion. There is absolutely no proof for any of them, and from a philosophical standpoint Christianity is not even the best." Of his time as a soldier in the trenches of WW I, one of the most cruel of wars, he proudly boasted that he “never sank so low as to pray.” While promoting atheism, he also dabbled in the occult, the paranormal, and in attempts to contact the dead. But, in 1929 he began to admit the existence of God and in 1931 he committed himself to Christianity. Lewis didn’t just change his mind and become a Christian. He made a complete about face and became a devout Christian, a spokesman for and defender of the faith. The question of how that could happen is certainly worth study, but C. S. Lewis himself wrote about his journey toward conversion in his book, “Surprised by Joy.” Others have written on the subject also. Why do we need another one?  

Lewis’ own book deals a lot with the struggle inside and the lifelong search for “joy” which he would not define as most of us would. For him “joy” was something pure and could never be based on anything unreal, imagined, or untrue. With his belief in the meaningless of life and the despair that it produced, there was no place for that joy deep inside that is firm and secure, never fleeting and uncertain. He said,  "Nearly all I loved I believed to be imaginary; nearly all that I believed to be real, I thought grim and meaningless." Lewis tries to explain how he discovered that joy in Christianity. Other authors have also written, but most have focused on what happened, on how others influenced him. This book is well-researched, using original resources, and tries to show what was happening inside of Lewis’ mind through his writings as well as the events and the writings of others. 

And, they show no Pauline kind of conversion. They show a struggle, almost as if God was dragging him, kicking and screaming, to a knowledge of Him and yet without Lewis knowing that he was being pulled. Lewis’ conversion (or as this book calls it “re-conversion” since he grew up in a Christian home and as a child attempted to say his prayers and be devout) was reluctant as if he had tried every other avenue and no longer had a choice without being dishonest with the truth he was facing. 

If you’re not a fan of C. S. Lewis, you may well enjoy this book, but may also find it a bit slow and dry. If you are a fan, you will enjoy and savor watching the process unfold through the words in front of you. You’ll also enjoy reading of Lewis’ contact with famous names like Yates, Tolkein, G. K. Chesterton, George MacDonald. As noted, the book was well researched, but there was part of the book that involved a bit of speculation, and that was at the very end, at the time of the final decision to become not only a believer in God, but a Christian. But, it was clearly labeled as so and was very enjoyable. I only found that I was disappointed that the book ended. Yes, the author’s task was done and he had completed what he had set out to do, to describe how Lewis became the reluctant convert. Walter Hooper calls Lewis the "most thoroughly converted man I ever met." Finished with the journey of how he got there, I wanted to continue with him on the rest of his journey toward becoming such a spokesman for the faith, how he wrote all of the books that I love so much. 

Struggles behind the man

This is a story of a man best known for having the answers. It tells his story of struggles. It makes Mr. Lewis human and his writtings more powerful and less pure intelectual theory. A great book for anyone interested in CS Lewis writtings and how they were shaped.

Keep your thinking cap on!

A rewarding walk through Lewis's thoughtful journey to truth. A welcome refutation of the present creeping darkness around us all.