In this episode, Dan and Josh respond to a portion of episode 538 on the Meat Eater podcast where musky fishing was discussed. They address the misconceptions and criticisms raised by the hosts and provide a more accurate perspective on musky fishing. They discuss the history of musky fishing, the importance of catch and release, the significance of different musky strains, and the conservation efforts to restore musky populations. They also highlight the role of musky fly fishing in the resurgence of musky fishing and challenge the notion that it is a recent trend. The conversation explores the topic of musky fly fishing and its impact on the musky community. The hosts discuss the reasons why they engage in musky fly fishing, including the challenge and the desire for a more ethical approach to catching and releasing muskies. They also address the contradictions within the musky world, such as the focus on catch and release while using methods that may harm the fish. The conversation delves into the controversy surrounding world record muskies and the dilemma of whether to certify and potentially kill a record-breaking fish. Overall, the hosts emphasize the importance of preserving muskies and finding a balance between conservation and angling.